It is fairly common for we citizens of the U.S.A. to think of
ourselves as the premier country of the world. Like the British Empire we have
a feeling of manifest destiny, that God intends for us to be the leaders of the
world in all ways: economically, politically, spiritually, culturally etc. And
we Christians of the country think of ourselves in a similar way. Early in our
country’s history religious leaders perceived ourselves as God new chosen
people and that we practice religion/Christianity better than other believers
in others countries.
And in our education we have been taught that this is true, at
least by our educators in the primary and secondary schools systems and our
books read that way. We used to laugh to Russians saying the invented things
before we knew we have invented those things.
Not everyone agrees with this. It might be fairly safe to say,
hardly anyone outside of our country believes this. In fact, those who have
received a solid liberal arts education and learned more real history don’t
believe it either.
Now let me head back into history. We are most familiar with
western history particularly the Greek and Roman thinkers and political leaders
and the history of Europe and ultimately at that leading up to American
history.
Part of that history included the persecution of Christians by the
Roman conquers who fed Christians to the lions, blamed them for the burning of
Rome and the like. Then in the Roman Emperor Constantine (306 – 337) came to
power and he had a vision of a Cross in the sky which meant to him in this sign
you shall conquer. So, he converted to Christianity and forced everyone to
convert with him or suffer the consequences – death. Suddenly Christianity is
the major religion and spreads all over the western world where Rome flexed its
might. It is rather a vicious history,
but one we are accustomed to and justify by various means.
Now a few years after Constantine another fella was born in 570 in
the Arabian city of Mecca. He shared many of the ideas and history of the
Christians and the Jews from which Christianity sprang. He believed in a
monotheistic God, the same God. He was part of the history of the Middle
Eastern people who came from Abraham and Sarah. He came from the line of
Ishmael, Abraham’s first son by his wife’s handmaiden Hagar. But when Sarah had
her own baby in their dotage, she thought that Hagar had gotten to big for her
britches (or whatever the Middle eastern equivalent for women of that time
was,) and asked her hubby to kick Hagar and her son Ishmael out and Abraham did
that. Mohammed became a great prophet in the line of great prophets of the line
of Abraham and wrote his teachings and ideas down in a book called the
Koran/Quran. The Muslims think that Mohammed restored the monotheistic faith of
Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus (accepting him as the messiah) and the other
prophets.
Now let’s jump to the time between 1095 and 1291 when the
Christians of that time decided that their cousins, the Muslims, the Islamic
folk were bad dudes not following their version of Judeo-Christian teachings
and therefore should be converted or destroyed. Thus begins the crusades, not
one of the finer moments of western history or Christianity. The Christians
used the idea of the just war to make this carnage more palatable. This action
did not make the Christians and the Moslems buddies.
In the modern era we Westerners, particularly the U.S.A. have fought just wars again against each
other and parts of the world. In our second “great war” to end all wars we
dropped the atom bomb, which scared the bejebbers out of everyone, and the war
ended; therefore it must have been the right things to do. But since we’ve done
it before, folk may not trust us to do it again.
Following these great wars the U.S.A. became the great economic
power of the world, a superpower and now the only one of these left. We are
well known for our consumerism even if it comes at the expense of others.
Now some folk see us as evil folk, who wish to dominate the world,
who live by false materialistic values, and do not follow the teachings on God
whatever the name of that God may be. I wonder why?
Those who have become the most radical in that belief that we are
not a very moral people believe we are the devil incarnate and should be
destroyed, even though their own teachings teach against that. But then, why
should they be any more moral than Constantine, the Crusaders and other folk?
I am not writing this to justify the actions of jihadists, they are
whacko. They are like the Klu Klux Klan of our own country when they, in the
name of Jesus, killed, raped and degraded black folk in this country they had
stolen from others countries.
But we need to keep things in perspective and understand the
history most of have been taught has been greatly skewed to make us look better
than we are.
So, if you are a person who condemns all Islamic people as
scoundrels, maybe you need to rethink your position. If you don’t have a friend
who is a Muslim and have had open conversations with them you are more subject
to scapegoating and name calling without serious thoughtful reflection. Most
Americans just don’t know much about the Muslim religion and just react to the
radical extremists and condemn the whole religion. That is not different that
condemning all of Christianity based upon the actions of the Klu Klux Klan.
Or, go and re-read my previous article on “We have met the enemy
and he is us.”
I do not write this article to demean us or anyone else. I write it
to show that we are all basically the same. We can do what is wonderful and we
can do what is awful. But we always need to talk and to be open with each
other.
The Crusades were presaged by a similar event, in which Muhammad's hordes raped and pillaged and conquered the Holy Land area, but they were earlier and came from the southeast (Arabia interior) instead of western Europe. For modern Muslims to moan about the latter atrocity and not the first is hypocritical.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteEverybody is a hypocrite. Everyone exhibits immoral behavior; that is my point. Pointing fingers at each other does not help; shaking hands with each other and talking does. Demonizing others doesn't solve problems it creates them, humanizing each makes for a better world.
ReplyDeleteThat is why I wrote the article to show our own foibles while humanizing does society is so quick to condemn in masse.
After conquering the Holy Land, the Muslims were tolerant of
ReplyDeletethe Jewish inhabitants; so much so that as the Crusaders moved through Europe killing any Jews to be found, those in
the Holy Land met them in arms (the defense of Haifa is an example). Both Jews and native Christians were slaughtered in Jerusalem's streets. As the native Americans learned how to take scalps from the encroaching Europeans, the Muslims
learned from the Normans to terminate prisoners. That was a thousand years ago, and we need understand the context of the times. Through the ensuing pogroms, the agonizing Reconquista and Luther's view of the Jews we now view with
some amusement the Christian fundamentalist uber support for
Israel and the concurrent distrust of American Jews for the far right folk. "show our own foibles" indeed.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIt is good to remember that when God gave the Jews the Promised Land that Moses was not allowed to enter; there were already people there, the Canaanites. So perhaps we should just blame God for everything. But that's not very helpful either.
ReplyDeleteIt is odd how this country claims to be Christian and yet as BB-Idaho mentioned the Christian fundamentalists are adamant supporter of the Israelites vs the Palestinian who have a large Christian contingent and as BB says remain anti-Jewish.
I keep reminding myself the point of this blog is civil discussion.
There were a lot of good points though. Aside from the fact that the Muslim invaders were very intolerant of the indigenous Jews in the Holy Land... but just less interant than invading Crusaders.
ReplyDelete